Coconut Café de Olla Popsicles with a Butterscotch Magic Shell

Coconut Café de Olla Popsicles with a Butterscotch Magic Shell

It’s #PopsicleWeek!

I’m really excited because it’s Billy’s 5th year putting this on, but my very first year participating!

We were both living in Eureka, on our last semesters of College when he hosted his first Popsicle Week, and I’m so proud to see how far he’s come with this popsicle lovefest. This year Billy was given a spread in the summer issue of AllRecipes Magazine for popsicle week, and he also did a Facebook Live with AllRecipes where he made these really good ginger piña colada and blueberry cobbler popsicles.

If you’re interested in seeing what else everyone contributed, head here. There are over 120+ contributors this year!

Coconut Café de Olla Popsicles with a Butterscotch Magic Shell

There were a few ideas I had in mind for popsicle week. My initial idea was to make these paletas de vainilla which have become an icon in Colima. Unfortunately, I was only able to find the specific popsicle molds in industrial sizes so I’m going to have to wait until I go back to Mexico to look for said molds. My second idea was to create a café de olla popsicle, which is what we’re making today. If you’re not familiar with café de olla, you’re missing out. It’s one of my favorite things to have for breakfast whenever we’re in Mexico, especially when we’re dining at one of our favorite spots in Comala, Los Portales de Suchitlan, who happen to package their own fresh coffee on-site!

It’s an al-fresco setting and you basically dine in the middle of coffee trees and other greenery, and it makes you feel like you’re eating in the middle of a jungle. Depending on who’s making your café de olla, it’ll be typically made by brewing coffee with really good piloncillo, Mexican cinnamon and in certain places people will also include a bit of orange peel for aromatics. I decided to leave out the orange peel out of the popsicles because I’ve never been a huge fan, and I think I have those bitter strips of candied citrus peel on the rosca de reyes to blame.

In this recipe we’ll be adding coconut milk for an extra layer of flavor and then dipping them in butterscotch and if you’re feeling a little daring, add a pinch of sea salt before the magic shell completely hardens for that sweet, salty and creamy experience. If you’re looking for the popsicle mold I used, you can find it here.

Have a happy 4th of July!

Coconut Café de Olla Popsicles with a Butterscotch Magic Shell

Coconut Cafe de Olla Popsicles with a Butterscotch Sea Salt Magic Shell
Makes 10 3oz popsicles. This is the mold I used.
Recipe type: Popsicles
  • For the popsicles:
  • 1 cup shredded coconut
  • 2 14oz cans full fat coconut milk (check weight)
  • 2 7.5oz. cans table cream*
  • 1 cup of coffee beans, crushed roughly with a heavy pot or rolling pin
  • 2 2” Mexican cinnamon sticks, each broken into quarters
  • 7 oz piloncillo, grated, about 1 cup (from 1 ½ 5oz piloncillo cones)
  • ½ tsp. Mexican Vanilla
  • *If you can't find the can of table cream you can just use 2 cups of half n half or make it vegan and use another 14oz can of coconut milk
  • For the Magic shell:
  • 12.oz cup butterscotch chips
  • 2 tbsp coconut oil
  • Sea Salt (optional)
  1. For the Popsicles
  2. Start by toasting the coconut in a dry medium sized saucepan over medium heat, stirring frequently to make sure it doesn't burn. Once the coconut is a light golden brown add the coconut milk and table cream (or alternatives).
  3. Bring this mixture to a simmer then add the crushed coffee beans, cinnamon and piloncillo and simmer for another 5 minutes, or until the piloncillo has dissolved. Set the pot aside for 15-20 minutes to let the mixture steep then pour it through a very fine mesh strainer (reusable coffee filters are good for this) into a large measuring cup, add the vanilla extract, and set aside to cool completely
  4. Fill your molds and freeze for 1 hour then insert the popsicle sticks and freeze for at least 4 hours.
  5. For the Magic Shell:
  6. Add the butterscotch chips and coconut oil to a microwave safe bowl. Microwave in intervals of 30 seconds until the chips have completely melted, stirring after each interval. Once it's melted remove popsicles from the mold one at a time and spoon the magic shell over each one, (optional) topping with a pinch of sea salt and serving.



You Might Also Like